This eyeliner is great! Good color, pretty long-lasting. It does tend to smear after a long day, but not nearly as much as other natural eyeliners.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

This is one of my desert island products for sure! I suffer severe allergies to most eye makeup and finding an eyeliner that not only looks great, but doesn't send my eyes into a days-long reaction has been a godsend! However, I am heartbroken that Tarte has chosen to discontinue some of its best colors: blue and gray. Unfortunately, the brown and plum eyeliners have caused terrible reactions (I've tried both), so I'm left with black (have not tried.....I am using what I have left of my blue and gray liners). I would be thrilled if the blue and gray returned to the lineup.

PLEASE Tarte Gods, bring back the other colors!!!!!!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

I love this eyeliner! I use it everyday and it has replaced my gel eyeliners. It makes a perfect line! I would highly recommend it. I am going to order more colors.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

I just bought a kit at Sephora and it had the emphasEYES inner rim brightener - which is a peach shade. I first thought I would love this liner to wear on my bottom inner rim to give my eyes that pop. I like it fair enough but I'm really impressed by wearing it in the inner corner to make me look more awake - it really does a great job at giving a fine line and glides on very easy. I wish there was a way to keep the tip as small as it is when you first buy it.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

I just LOVE this little eyeliner. The tiny little tip makes it so easy to line your eyes, whether top or bottom and make it come out so clean looking, and professional. When I want a thicker line, I'll reach for the clay liners, but for thin liners, this is the bomb. Doesn't take much to make it look great. Gets right down into those lashes and makes the lashes look naturally dark at the bases. It's awesome. Does have a tendency to break, if you're not careful, but once you realize that, you know how to deal with it. Great product, once again.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Love the thinness and the creaminess of this liner. The shades are beautiful. And it doesn't need to be sharpened which is really convenient.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

I absolutely love these for tight lining. I wear contacts and I find that these stay put, do not smudge, and do not irritate my eyes. The plum is my favorite. I really brings out my blue eyes.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Love the slim application. Colors are beautiful. Stays put nicely.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

I went to a training for Tarte, and this was a gift I rec'd for attending. I love this product. It is great for creating a thin base line on the upper lashes to cover with a sultry shadow to achieve an awesome smokey look, or for the water-line on the lower lashes. Since that area of the eye is naturally wet, anything you apply in that area will eventually wear-off as the day continues; however, a little trick that helps with my wear of this product is drying the water line with your finger (clean of course) or Q-tip prior to applying it, and if you want setting it with a dark colored shadow. That greatly extends the wear in the inner-rim or water-line. Great product!!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

I have it in charcoal and am not a good inner-rimmer, so I use it on my upper lashline. Lasts pretty much all day, but does run a little if used on the bottom lashiline. Very dense pigment, though, so usually one swipe does the trick.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Absolutly love how thin of a line it draws. It blends well, to create an awesome smoky look. I wish it was water proof, but it holds up throughout the day.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

For me this is just to skinny. It bothers my eye when i am applying it.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

I have it in charcoal. Love the color and texture and the effect is great looking. However, when it comes to the inner rim, if I wanted to keep the look I'd have to re-apply every two hours. It's nice as a regular eyeliner, but it really doesn't seem to be formulated for the inner rim which is the reason I purchased it in the first place.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

This is the first product I have ever used on the inner rims of my eyes, and it made my eyes look great. It made making a smoky eye extremely easy.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

These pencils are amazing! Super pigmented and I love how they are so thin. My only complaint is that if you advance them too much they break really easily, but other than that.... I'M IN LOVE WITH THIS PRODUCT!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

One of my favorite eyeliners of all time! The tiny point really helps you get into the waterline nicely and really makes your eyes seem pretty. The colors are all super pigmented and don't smudge or migrate much. At the end of the day my eyeliner has faded slightly and it's a bit smudged, but that's at the end of a busy day! Besides, it's so easy to reapply and if you do reapply like I do, then you don't need to worry about smudging! I wish I could say that I owned all the colors, but hopefully soon I will!

Would you buy this product again? Yes