93% would buy this product again.
Pamela from NY
on 10/11/2011
Not bad, but not outstanding either... Definitely use a primer for more staying power and truer color Would you buy this product again? Yes
Molly from MN
on 08/13/2011
I love the color and application. I wish you had more colors available...especially some more pastel pinks, roses, purples, teals, etc. Would you buy this product again? Yes
Jennifer from CA
on 08/11/2011
I LOOOOOVE tarte eyeshadow. I think 17 bucks for a pan is a little extreme. My suede case from 2000 is ruined. I am disappointed that I cannot have another reasonably sized palette. I love that you make refillable products, but you need to offer them for a broader base, like for girls that don't need 18 million eyeshadow pans floating around. I'm very fair skinned and the idea of having 12 pans of eyeshadow is beyond overkill for me. All of the new palettes have several colors I could never use. Very disappointed the single/doubles are not available anymore. There was a coral colored eyeshadow in the old Spring Greening palette that I would kill to replace. Would you buy this product again? Yes
Janie from OK
on 08/11/2011
Love TARTE eye shadows. I have several palettes and some are refillable but there are hardly any colours to choose from. Please increase the selection as I wear no other eyeshadow. I also feel this lack of selection kind of makes the selling point of refillable palettes rather ridiculous if you are not going to offer replacement colours. Would you buy this product again? Yes
Janette from MI
on 03/25/2011
bought the natural palette because it was refillable, but there appears to be an extremely limited number of refill colors. I want refills for the colors that are in the palette. What the heck??
I love the shadows, used to use MAC for years, changed due to the ingredients, but if I can't get the colors without buying another palette? Not good sense... Would you buy this product again? Yes
Judy from CO
on 03/24/2011
i like the colors especially the nudes and browns, although I haven't quite found the right applicator to use. In the kit I have it had no applicator and everything I have used from a sponge type to brush the eyeshadow powders fall onto my cheeks.. they don't seem to stay on the applicator and only my lids... Would you buy this product again? Yes
Heidi from MO
on 02/24/2011
I love tarte's eye shadows. They go on smooth and even. I can use one layer for casual day wear or if I want a more dramatic look for night time I just layer the powders until I get the look I want and it's so smooth it doesn't look caked on. Would you buy this product again? Yes
Anna from TX
on 02/19/2011
please put more pigment into these. there seems to be lacking pigment. also, please make more individual shades like M.A.C.'s variety of shades of eyeshadows. i like mac but stopped using them due to harmful chemicals and i find that tarte is a good replacement. also a palette like mac's would be great to put these in. i would also like individual colors that come in palettes to be available for individual purchase. thanks. more light shades like white and shimmering white and more matte and shimmery and satin neutrals please thanks Would you buy this product again? Yes
kelly from VA
on 02/04/2011
I love these eyeshadows and the other reviewers really nailed it...high pigment, long lasting, but very disappointing that there are so few colors offered. That's the only reason I didn't give it 5 stars! Would you buy this product again? Yes
Jennifer from CA
on 12/02/2010
Best eyeshadow ever! Blends like a dream and stays put. Women ask me all the time what eyeshadow I use. I wish Tarte would have a slightly broader selection in the individuals, maybe a few more neutrals that would be universal? Would you buy this product again? Yes
Emma from CA
on 11/01/2010
great pigment formula and excellent choice of colors! i love how they are refillable so it's not so wasteful. already have two of the colors, and they vary from being matte or shimmery. can't wait for my next one! and it lasts forever... Would you buy this product again? Yes
Lisa from CA
on 10/04/2010
Love the individual colors. All of them look so pretty on the eyes and they are free of harsh additives!! Great for sensitive eyes. The fact they can be refilled into the palette reduces waste and I love that!! Would you buy this product again? Yes
I have the color sweet valley high, which is closet to the pink shade pictured. It's a very light pink-nude shade with a lot of shimmer. It is my absolute favorite eyeshadow ever. The packaging is adorable, a tiny purple box that even has a mirror! I use this on all parts of my eye, as a highlighter on my browbone, as a lid color, a crease color, and I've even experimented with using it as a liner color. No matter where I put it, this color is amazing. It's velvety smooth and despite how light the color is, it is very pigmented and a little goes a long way. I know I'll need to get a few more of these shadows, I'm in love! Would you buy this product again? Yes
This eyeshadow goes on great with or without an eyeshadow primer. If you're looking for a bolder look, I highly recommend using one. It goes on so smooth and evenly and really makes your eyes pop. It's highly pigmented so a little goes a long way. By far my favorite eyeshadow out there! Would you buy this product again? Yes
| 
