Cinnamon from TX
on 04/07/2012

I absolutely love this eyeliner! It goes on great and stays just as well. Please don't stop making it!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Kristina from TX
on 03/14/2012

I am terrible at applying liquid eyeliner and this one is no different for me. I actually use the powder as eyeliner and it works great! Whenever I want dramatic eyes, I use the liquid side but the other side is great for every day use.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Beth from MO
on 03/11/2012

like another reviewer said, I have problems applying this without getting it on my lashes. it's a fantastic liner, and the shadow really gives it that extra finishing touch for an incredible look, but i'm left with clumpy lashes. I really need to perfect application of this so that I can enjoy it!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

jamie from TX
on 02/16/2012

love it. So convenient. I have brown eyes so I love the brown. So far I love all Tarte products!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Grace from TX
on 12/21/2011

I accidentally gave this product only 4 1/2 stars in my review (i'm typing from a smartphone). Five stars! I'd give it 10 stars if i could. Please don't discontinue!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Grace from TX
on 12/21/2011

This is the BEST liquid eyeliner ever. The felt tip is sturdy so application is easy, and the color stays on forever. I heard a rumor this eyeliner was going to be discontinued. Please tell me this isnt true!!!!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Alex from AZ
on 12/01/2011

[ Customer did not submit review ]

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Evelyn from MD
on 10/04/2011

Two great products in one. How amazing and convenient !!!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

on 07/25/2011

I really like this color and it is a wonderful color! You should get it!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

jenny from NV
on 06/05/2011

it works really good!!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

stephanie from OR
on 04/14/2011

This is actuallly a really great product in in every way. The only reason I can't give it 5 stars is that I don't like the applicator on the liquid side. It drives me crazy that that the brush isn't exactly a brush and doen't have full movement for a more perfect line. Otherwise... I love this.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Erin
on 03/26/2011

I do love this product, I wish the shadow "tip" was a bit smaller though, I like having a little more control than what this tip offers.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Anna from TX
on 02/20/2011

i would really like to see more shades. i love liquid liners but the only shade here is chocolate

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Beth from MO
on 02/11/2011

Although I love the way this eyeliner performs, I have to take one star off for the fact that I can't seem to manage putting it on without getting tons of it on my eyelashes, making them stick together and clump when I apply mascara. I love the consistence of it, and the waterproof aspect, but I wish it were slightly slower to dry just so that I could wipe it off of my lashes. I do feel this is a flaw on MY part, not that of the product itself. Layering the powder over the liner creates an AMAZING smokey eye line.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Victoria from FL
on 01/07/2011

Gosh this was a life saver! When it comes to getting a look like this you need abouch of loose stuff then needing a make-up bag. all you got to do with this is open it up and your set. I love it. But it needs more colors.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Mindy from IN
on 01/03/2011

Amazing staying power! I can wear this to work during the day & add the shadow to it for the night out! Definitely recommend!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Joyti from CA
on 01/02/2011

I love how it made my eyes pop and it literally stayed on until I removed my makeup and washed my face. I have it in plum and want to get it in black and charcoal. I hope its available. Cant wait to try different looks with it.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Abby
on 10/02/2010

I got this in plum a while back and I LOVE the color! It's a great shade for when you want to use a liquid liner but are looking for something lighter and different than classic black. It's not an intense purple at all, more like a metallic purple-brown color. I haven't used the powder shadow side much but when I want a smoky eye, I'll smudge some along the lashline after using the liner. If I want a sharper look, I'll forgo the shadow. Sometimes I'll use the powder shadow alone but only after using a good primer, since the sponge applicator tends to create some fallout. One thing I do love about the applicator is that it can be used to add a very concentrated amount of product at once. The liner doesn't flake or wear out, but removes pretty easily with a q-tip and some makeup remover.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Jane from WA
on 08/06/2010

LOVE this eyeliner and I wish it came in more colors. I'm not graceful with liquid eyeliner but find the applicator in this one is easy to use. I also use the powder to help even out "mistakes" and to soften the line a bit. I have the plum color and use it along with emphasEYES in plum.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Kristen from OR
on 08/03/2010

If you like liquid eyeliner, you'll like this. Easy to apply, stays all day without smudging. Not waterproof, but water resistant. The powder not only sets the liner, it can help create the smoky eye look. So easy to have either the sharp lines or a more blended look with this.

Would you buy this product again? Yes