I really wanted to like this mascara but it was too thick and clumpy for me. I guess I prefer a defining mascara. My lashes seemed to stick together with it. I don't own a lash comb - maybe that would have helped. It definitely made my lashes stand out, though.

I have 2 sisters and we all loved this mascara,
The natural ingredients are really important because I bought it for my teanaged sister.
We all have long lashes so we didn't really need it to be lengthening. What we really loved was the non clumping!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

This is the best mascara I've ever used (and I've used some quite a bit more expensive). It's very dramatic but it does not look clumpy or flaky. I curl my eyelashes before I apply it and this mascara keeps them in place well throughout the day. Especially considering that its natural and works this well, I'd say it's a great value.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

This is by far, one of my very favorite mascaras if not # 1. I love a dramatic lash and this works perfectly every time! I love how major it makes my lashes look! I can't say enough good things. Plus the natural ingredients are a huge deal! I really prefer using natural products and this delivers excellent results as well. Really great! I wish it was slightly cheaper, but I can deal with that. It is so worth it!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

This mascara is the absolute best!!!....no clumping..stays put, long lush lashes....I will not be without it. Just ordered more today.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

This is a fantastic mascara!!! I adore it! For a natural mascara it doesn't clump, flake or otherwise get it my eyes at any time. It makes my lashes look awesome, and I have naturally long lashes anyway. I love that it's a natural product, especially because it's around my eyes. It's a great product and it works wonders. Who wouldn't love it???

Would you buy this product again? Yes

I redeemed my Sephora Beauty Insider points for a Tarte kit, which included this as a well as the waterproof version. I LOVE this mascara! It gives me plumper, longer lashes, and doesn't clump! I will definitely purchase a full size version!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

I ran out of my favorite mascara but this one is the best mascara I've used so far. I think it's the natural ingredients that make this so great for me. My eyelashes stay long and beautiful with this on plus it's not hard to take off.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Love it!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Cute packaging, really lengthens. I wish it would curl my lashes a bit more but it a great product and great value.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

This was the first Tarte product I tried. I got it as a trial size in a mascara/eyeliner set at Sephora. I absolutely love this mascara. Hands down, it gives my lashes the most volume out of any of the mascaras I've ever tried.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

This is my favorite mascara right now. my lashes look really nice and natural but i still get a little bit of drama from it which is awesome. It doesn't bleed or look cakey or clumpy. I totally want to try the waterproof next time.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Great mascara, doesn't leave your lashes dry and clumpy. Washes off easily and doesn't take lashes with it down the sink, either! Lovely product.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

This mascara is phenomenal! It doesn't clump, it plumps and the best part is that it's natural!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Leaves your lashes in very good shape. No real flaking, great at lengthening. Overall a good product. Holds up fairly well against water, but not waterproof. Which is the only reason it does not get 5 stars.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

I love this mascara! its awesome.The package is beautiful, and it really lengthens and volumizes.Im buying again!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

I didn't notice much curling action from this mascara on its own but after using my curler it sealed the curve right in place! It doesn't smudge and the brush grabs all of the little hairs and coats them evenly without clumping up like others I've tried!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

This mascara is FABULOUS!!!

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Cute packaging, and this did not smudge or flake on me. This also holds my curl the day, which is rare for a non-waterproof mascara.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

Probably the best mascara I have ever used - it gives thick, long gorgeous lashes that no other product has been able to emulate. It would be a five star product but for it doesn't seem to last as long as other mascaras, so you have to buy more frequently.

Would you buy this product again? Yes

If there was a mascara holy grail, this would be it! My lashes aren't terrible but they aren't as long or as plump as I would like. lights, camera, lashes! actually does both...plumps and lengthens. I've even been asked if I'm wearing false eyelashes a few times. This product never flakes and never leaves traces behind on my eye lid, even when I apply it too soon after my eye cream. And it comes off easily with my regular cleanser. I'm sure I sound like I work for Tarte (I don't); I'm just totally head-over-heels in love with lights, camera, lashes!

Would you buy this product again? Yes