Maricella

about 3 weeks, 3 days ago

At first I loved it! But then after a few months it dried out. And each time I would sharpen it, a big piece would break off. I would probably not repurchase it. I hope it was just a defective product and not the line.

Cynthia

about 3 weeks, 6 days ago

I credit my sister who had gotten me started on these skinny eye pencils. These are smooth, creamy, and stays put if you wipe away the excess moisture from your eyes first. We first tried it from QVC, then bought from Sephora, then this website! Please sell a trio of the black pencils and a trio of the different brown ones too!

Kelly

on 05/06/2013

I'm a huge tarte fan, but this product isn't my absolute favorite. I have crazy sensitive eyes, so that's probably the reason behind it, but I tend to have more problems with watery eyes and my contact when I wear this liner, I've noticed. What I will say is fantastic about it is its easy application, the built in smudger, and the colors. I have it in onyx and amazonite blue (obsessed with the color). Not sure if I'd buy again just because, like I said, my eyes are abnormally sensitive, but I'd still recommend it.

Dena

on 05/06/2013

This is going be the only eyeliner I use from now on. I'm in love with it. Comes on easily and smoothly. And it stays on, doesn't smear. I use it on the inner lining of my eye. It works perfectly.

Carolyn

on 04/29/2013

I LOVE this liner! This is the softest, easiest to apply liner I have ever owned! Plus it stays put and does not bother my sensitive eyes.

Darlene

on 04/23/2013

I bought the Christmas edition and it had one of these in it and I have to say I loved it and I do set it with a little shadow from Tarte because I am active.But it is so soft going on and non-irritating.

Chelsea

on 04/19/2013

Um...does anyone else find these pencils incredibly difficult to sharpen? My poor pencil is totally, utterly mangled. I know it's not my sharpener because I've run other pencils through it and they turned out fine. I even put it in the freezer for 20 minutes, like other people have suggested online, and no dice. The tip is so smooshy, you have to be really delicate with it -even when you're applying it. I love the color (Moonstone Brown), but unless there is a way to sharpen these things without them totally being destroyed, I won't be repurchasing.

Brittany

on 04/19/2013

I got this in a kit and I was really excited because it is supposed to be all day wear. It did not do the trick especially on the bottom lashes which the area that runs and I have trouble with frequently from getting raccoon eyes. I was not really impressed with this product.

Kelcey

on 04/10/2013

Still smears in the pool. I would buy again, but not as a waterproof item.

kelley

on 04/05/2013

I love love love the smolder eyes eyeliner in the fatter pencil but this is AMAZING!!!!

Tara

on 04/02/2013

I love this eyeliner. I got it in Amazonite Blue and not only is the color absolutely gorgeous, it wears beautifully, doesn't smear or smudge, and the color is more versatile than I hoped. I first apply a line of MultiplEYE liquid eyeliner on the top lash line (another product I highly recommend) and let it dry. Then I put a layer of this over the top of that and on my bottom lashline. It really makes my blue eyes pop. I want to collect more colors but am disappointed to see there's no dark/navy blue. Please oh please add a navy blue color to this eyeliner line Tarte!

Natalie

on 03/30/2013

I absolutely love this eyeliner! It goes on so smoothly and lasts all day. I bought it in deep amethyst and it is the prettiest purple color and looks great with my brown eyes. I usually don't finish pencil eyeliners but I use this so often I've almost used it all up. Just bought it again in moonstone brown and can't wait to try it. The only reason I didn't give it a full 5 stars is because I go through it so fast for such an expensive liner but I think it's still worth it.

Whitney

on 03/29/2013

This is one of the best eyeliner pencils I have ever used! It glides on very smoothly and stays all day.

ANDREA

on 03/22/2013

Have never been a fan of pencil eyeliners but I am definitely a fan of this! It goes on so smooth and easy and lasts all day. Just make sure to pay attention what your doing so you don't skew off somewhere else...I might be making a confession here. Great colors...I want to try just about all of them!

Jeanniece M.

on 03/15/2013

My new favorite eye pencil. I bought it in black. I usually prefer the gel or pen liners over even the best pencil liners. This looks just as good and is just as smooth and inky as the best gel liners (even yours).

I have the thick one in the prettiest navy I have ever used, that love it almost as much as this skinny pencil, but the control and versatility of the skinny pencil really inspires me. Utterly tuggles and an amazing color payoff. It's blendable, but once it sets it doesn't budge, run or smear.

I came online today to purchase more colors.