okay "I bought the colors gaze, smolder, sultry and smoke show. The colors look different in person than in the photo which is true for most of tarte's products on the website. Smolder is a darker shade almost black/dark brown with a slight plum tone. Not the purple you see on the photos. Sultry is a dark brown with slight golden/bronze shimmer when the light hits it. Mine came defective but customer service was helpful. Smoke show is a grayish mauve satin, very pretty, not as dark as smolder or sultry. Gaze is much too light and it does not show up on lighter skin tones. It does last, it is pigmented and glides on creamy and smooth but you may need to do 2-3 layers for color payoff, as 1 layer is more subtle. Tips do wear down pretty fast before you need to sharpen. The tip is rounded and no way to get a sharp line like it shows on the website. They used to come with a sharpener and i wish these still did. I got it at a good price, full price is to high. Overall, I do like it but there are things to consider, like the price, drying out the lids, fast wear down and colors look different in person than online. I hope this was helpful to someone." — cindy b. (3/5)
Great! "This eyeliner is great. Goes on smooth and has great staying power. I got envy and it works great over my lids and my corners for a natural look. It also has a nice subtle sparkle to it." — Sharon W. (5/5)
You CAN sharpen these. And they last all day. "Get the very wide sharpener from a brand that starts with "R", pull the insert out. Sharpen these. $3 from a store "A". It works beautifully. The sharpener has 2 holes but can sharpen 3 sizes of pencils. Pull the insert out. You're golden. Don't miss out on these. I have 5 colors. Last all day, no touch-ups and don't embarrassed me. Makes my eyes look amazing!!" — JoLee (5/5)
Great Eyeliner "I bought this eyeliner in the color Seduce. I use it for a liner, not an overall eyeshadow. It is creamy, glides on nice, and has good color payoff. I am happy with my purchase." — Supo12 (5/5)
Love This Must have "Love this color the ease of application and the gentle blending. I can go dramatic and bold or use it as a gentle accent to my outfit It covers the plain with a pop the color is rich this tone highlights my golden tan skin color the pigment is natural" — Dolleen W. (5/5)
EXCELLENT STAYING POWER!! "Love this eye liner, I put it on & even if it’s raining or you have a sweaty face it doesn’t move. I use makeup remover to remove it. Just love it, best liner I’ve ever used." — Sheri W. (5/5)
My new favorite! "I've only used it as a liner. Love that I can use it as a thin or bolder liner and it stays all day! I have it in 2 colors, charm & smolder and love them both." — Angie F. (5/5)
Pretty good…. "Wear it alone as an eye brightener for no makeup days. Pretty good but prefer Tarte palettes." — Maria H. (4/5)
Great eyeliner BUT… "This is a great eyeliner and I love how long it lasts. What I don’t understand is, why wouldn’t you sell this with the option to buy a sharpener with it??? The one I have completely broke the entire tip off and ruined it. This wasn’t thought through well at all. What it comes down to is I bought this and could only use it for 2 weeks. PLEASE SELL A SHARPENER WITH IT" — Tricia (2/5)
