"I love this color! It is so pretty with a darker brown or on its on! Application is easy, but the smudger is too hard and doesn’t work well. The liner atays put, even after many hours." — Kerry (5/5)
"I love this color and it stays well, but the smudger is very hard and the liner doesn’t blend well with it. I had better luck using my finger." — Kerry (4/5)
LOVE! "I never knew how much I needed this in my life before I got it! This liner goes on so smoothly and creates a little wider of a line so that it leaves the perfect shadow. I love my smolder color, and am looking forward to filling out the rest of my collection!" — Mandy D. (5/5)
Poor design "Ordered this, loved the color n sparkle of it but the poor design of the pencil doesn’t let u sharpen it. Maybe if it was thinner 🤷🏽♀️ but more than half of it will b wasted. Unfortunate." — Caroline W. (2/5)
Smolder eyes "I love these chubby sticks of eye color! They give me the look I love to wear without working at layering the color. Easy and fast application. I have quite a few colors though I use black most often." — C O. (5/5)
Really beautiful color that goes on easily "I've been buying from Tarte long enough to remember the previous original SmolderEyes and I'm so glad they brought these back with so many colors! It goes on very easily without tugging or scratching, very buildable, and smudges nicely. My only issue is that SmolderEYES used to come with a little purple sharpener and these do not appear to . . . so having a sharpener would be ideal! I do plan to try many of the other colors!" — Anna S. (5/5)
Love it but impossible to sharpen "I love how smooth it is and the thicker coverage. . . but after a couple times sharpening it just won't sharpen anymore. It's too wide for a regular sharpener. One I ordered came with a little sharpener but it won't work anymore. The other one did not come with a sharpener." — Heidi (3/5)
"I love tart products, but I hated these. They color sunk right into my wrinkles on my eyes." — Kathryn (1/5)
Updating my previous one-star review - now 5⭐!! "Once I figured out the right pencil sharpener for this liner, I am extremely happy! It's creamy, easy to blend, lasts all day and makes my eyes look amazing! Colors are gorgeous! You need an 11mm pencil sharpener." — Linda (5/5)