Second tube was awesome
"I bought this as part of a BOGO sale. The first one I opened must have been dried out because it was awful. It didn't apply well and if I tried to correct it, it just pulled up what I had tried to put down before. I was ready to give up, but decided to give the second one a try and it's amazing! I have hooded lids and I don't use eye shadow, but I still had to apply powder to my lids to keep my regular eyeliner from transferring. I've used this now for over a week and it doesn't transfer! It comes off easily and looks great."


