Perfection "This pencil has a creamy texture that makes it easy to smudge out for a soft, smoky look. The color payoff is strong, and once it sets, it stays put surprisingly well. The downside is that because it’s so soft, the tip can wear down quickly and may need frequent sharpening. If you like a smudgy, lived‑in liner that doubles as shadow, it’s a solid pick." — Lisa T. (5/5)
Smolder Eyes Eye Liner "I absolutely loved this product but good luck trying to find a sharpener big enough for the liner to fit into. I purchased five separate sharpeners and nothing worked. Now I have an almost brand new eyeliner that I can’t use. Tarte should sell an eyeliner for this product. Do better Tarte!" — Cheryl (2/5)
Great combo! "I really appreciate the mascara! It gives length and volume without the crusty finish. Long, beautiful lashes lasts all day long. I really like the shadow liner. Once you put in place, blend it out. . it stays put! Lasts all day!" — Shannon R. (5/5)
Needs pencil sharpener, otherwise great "I like that this eyeshadow stick is easy to use, that it doesn't irritate my sensitive skin, and that it has a natural-looking colour. However, it needs an extra-large pencil sharpener in order for me to keep using it. Worth buying, but if you don't have a sharpener already, know that you'll need to invest in one." — Tawnie O. (4/5)
Zero staying power whatsoever "Super disappointed in this product. The size of it makes it easy to use, and the formula is creamy and glides on the skin without tugging. If only it didn't create the biggest mess on my face! Even after properly prepping and setting my makeup, this product completely failed me- Tammy Faye Baker vibes before my work day even began. Never again." — Kristina L. (1/5)
Love It "My favorite shadow liner. It goes on smooth, has great pigment, blends easily and lasts all day. I love this color!" — Joanne F. (5/5)
This is great! "I’ve never liked shadow liner pencils—-until now. I really like the way this applies, and if it fades a bit later in the day, I can revive it with a quick brush of my fingers. It’s so easy to use and less messy than powder shadow." — Diana B. (5/5)
Amazing on the eyes "Gorgeous formula, long lasting and best of all no creasing even on mature eyelids. Please come out with some more vibrant fun colours" — Nasheeda C. (5/5)
Brown eye color’s best friend "I love this item. I have a brown eyes and whenever I use this color eyeshadow my easy are seems gettin bigger ❤️" — Nurdan (5/5)
Love but need more matt colour options "This shadow liner is incredible- I use it on my whole eyelid as it is easy to apply. It's also quite pigmented so you don't need layer after layer. Lasts as well." — Gaelynn K. (4/5)
