Underwhelmed! "I have no idea how the people in the photos got the look they got. Maybe they added some type of primer? I put on 3 applications and I can barely tell I’m wearing mascara. There are drugstore brands that have a more impressive product. I’m used to black mascara. This doesn’t seem to be a dark black pigment. I have eyelashes that aren’t sparse, so that’s not the issue. Also, this one ends up under my eyes by the end of the day giving me the raccoon look. Very disappointed especially at this price point! I certainly don’t plan to repurchase." — Susie (1/5)
the only mascara I've used for the past 8 years "I have used this mascara for almost 8 years now. It is my favorite and if they ever stop making it I will not be okay. The secret is multiple fine coats to separate all the lashes and make them look super long." — Carolyn N. (5/5)
Staple mascara "The wand is perfect to get every lash coated, there’s no smudging even on hot days and I live in Texas with 100 degree weather. I ordered the brown shade and it’s perfect my lashes look more defined and longer. I will definitely order again" — Victoria L. (5/5)
No more clumping! "This is the best mascara I've found to date. I love the applicator brush with its short bristles. No more clumping!!" — Patricia H. (5/5)
Maneater Mascara is my favorite "I always come back to this one - the full bristled brush and ease of application is why this is my go to. Adds length and fullness without having to apply multiple applications." — Lindsey H. (5/5)