eye liner "This eyeliner is fantastic! It glides on smoothly with rich, intense color and makes it easy to create both subtle and bold looks. The formula is long-lasting, smudge-resistant, and stays in place all day without fading. Whether I’m doing a simple line or a wing, it gives me precise, flawless results every time. I highly recommend it!" — Niranjan P. (5/5)
Great Staying Power, But My Fine Lines Are Still Having a Party! "I really wanted this liner to be my new best friend, but it seems it and my fine lines have a different idea of a flawless look. While it definitely stays on all day, maybe a little too well, it has a bit of a habit of smudging and finding its way into every little crease around my eyes. If the tip were just a hair thinner, it would be perfection! It is great that it sticks around, but I am looking for something that respects my personal space and my wrinkles a little more. Still, for the staying power, it is a solid effort!" — Maribel S. (4/5)
Almost perfect "I like the angle of this eyeliner. It helps me apply so effortlessly and at a really nice angle. I also love the color. But the product has fallen out of the container a bit, and I seem to be going through it quickly. We’ll see how long it lasts for the price." — Allison W. (4/5)
It’s ok "I do have to say I was expecting a liner a little easier to use. While it’s very pigmented i prefer a strait or pointed point rather than a slanted one" — Allison L. (3/5)
Poor liner "This liner has been so frustrating! I love the Tarte products but this one fails. It's either super sharp to apply or the stick falls off into the sink when applying. There's no in between." — MelissA M. (1/5)
Best ever "I actually purchased it a few months ago and I loved it so much. I bought another one before the first one was even gone. It goes on so easily and stays on pretty long. Goes on so easy on your waterline and bottom." — Gina S. (5/5)
Easy eyeliner "Surprised at how much the thin slanted liner actually helped keep a stable line. Actually waterproof and did not smear off at end of day. One concern could be how little product is in the tube, so not sure how many weeks the container will last" — Ellen S. (5/5)
I’m obsessed "I love this so much I’m now afraid to run out. My only critique would be that I can’t tell when it’s getting low. To be fair though, that’s normal for any eye liners that aren’t basically a pencil you can sharpen so 🤷♀️" — Patricia B. (5/5)
Tricky to use on hooded lids "I can’t get the hang of it, but also have hooded lids and liners are more difficult for me. Even when I do get a smooth line on my upper lid, it does transfer so I am limited to tight line/water line use only." — Kelly C. (3/5)
