"This is my third or fourth pencil. I really like and use both the mascara and the pencil separately. I just not 100% sure about the shade. I prefer a cool-toned shade because I am a deep winter." — Vickie (5/5)
New fave! "Tarte is quickly taking over my whole makeup bag! Just decided to try in place of my previous brow pencil and brush. I love it!" — Amanda R. (5/5)
Hard to shade match "My hair is between a 5 and a 6 with highlights, so I was looking for a good neutral brown brow product. This one was too… auburn, almost? I knew the option for blondes would be too light and the darker one would be too dark. I like the pencil itself and the liquid to set it is okay. Just not the right color for me." — Arin S. (3/5)
travel-size sketch & set brow pencil & tinted gel "This is the best brow pencil I've ever tried. It looks so natural and the tinted gel sets my brows all day long. Does not rub off!" — KELLY M. (5/5)