Bring back the Holy Grail OG!!! "It's beyond me why Tarte would think changing one of their best selling products of all time would be a good idea. I know we're being dramatic but this is seriously DEVASTATING. 😭😭 The slight glow and perfect undertone made getting ready a breeze. I miss the original product so much." — Jame (1/5)
Not the same "This color is not the same as the original formula. It is very orange (and that comes from someone who doesn't mind being a little on the warmer side with make up). Definitely not the same product. I am scraping the pan on my old one still and there is a clear difference in color." — Rebecca G. (1/5)
Favorite bronzer "This is absolutely my favorite bronzer. Soft powder blends nicely that can be built up as wanted for contouring. The size of this is also very large and lots of very long time." — Rachel K. (5/5)
Love It "This is the perfect bronzer, blends well and leaves a smooth bronzed color." — Jessica W. (5/5)
I spent some time chatting with the Tarte customer service to verify that the product I ordered was the same as the product I loved. A "It is not the same product. Zero scent, it sparkles. It’s more pink. It’s a decent enough product for that just in the sun” look on my shoulders but I’m not putting this on my face. So I kept it. But I will not order it again. I would give 4 stars for this product, had it been the product I was after. Customer Service led me wrong, so one star it is. The original Amazonian Clay Bronzer in Park Avenue Princess shade was PERFECTION. It is beyond me why Tarte would change that." — Kerri B. (1/5)
Why would you change a perfect product?!?! "I am so disappointed and devastated! This is not the OG Park avenue princess bronzer. This pulls so orange!! I am a month out from my wedding and now I'm left scrambling trying to find something comparable. I cannot comprehend why tarte would make such a drastic change to such a beloved holy Grail product. Even the OG matte version was incredible and perfect for cool, neutral, and even warm skin tones. You are not Westmore beauty!! This product is absolute garbage and looks like a bad '90s bottle tan. Milani silky matte in sunlight is the only thing I've found that matches the matte original but it doesn't have the glow this had. Please bring back this original product!!!!" — Jame (1/5)
Just not as good as the original "Please bring back the original formula. I loved the light coconut smell and the build ability of the original product. The new one has a plastic odor that is not nice and goes on too heavy despite using the same application brush I always used with the original product. The original Amazonian clay product has been a staple of my daily routine for years with so many compliments of how tan I look. Please bring back the original formula." — Kacia M. (2/5)
Bring back Amazonian bronzer! "Not even close to the original Amazonian goddess bronzer. So disappointing. Tarte sold out just to change their formula to try and reinvent something that wasn’t broke, but instead made a disaster of a product. Bring back the original Amazonian clay bronzer!!!!!" — Jamie (1/5)
