Love the burgundy color!
"I love the color and liner texture. It is difficult to sharpen. Luckily I had a pencil sharpener large enough to fit it. The sharpener didn’t work that well. It would be great if one designed for the pencil came with it."
smolderEYES™ shadow liner
smolderEYES™ shadow liner

what it is
A waterproof shadow & eyeliner hybrid with a built-in smudger for easy, 30-second eyes—from everyday definition to a smoky eye.
why we love it
It’s giving smokeshow—in 30 seconds. smolderEYES™ shadow liner lets you line, shade, sculpt + smudge with 1 easy eye pencil. The waterproof formula glides on for precise definition, then blends seamlessly with the built-in smudger to create an effortless smoky eye without needing a brush or pro-level eyeshadow skills. Wear as eyeliner, blend across lids as shadow or mix + layer shades to create your own look. Choose from matte, shimmer + metallic finishes to take your eyes from soft daytime definition to full-on smoke. Vegan, cruelty-free, ophthalmologist tested & safe for contact lens wearers.
skinvigorating™ ingredients
shades
always formulated without: parabens • mineral oil • phthalates • triclosan • gluten & more
Overall rating: 4.3267045 / 5 from 352 reviews.
The smolderEYES™ shadow liner is praised for its ability to create a smoldering look, with smooth and pigmented eyeshadow sticks. Customers appreciate its long-lasting formula, smooth blends, and easy application. The color is also highly admired, and the product is noted for its effectiveness in creating a perfect smoky eye.
Review topics: ["color","results","feels","shipping","skin","texture","look","liner","eyes","shade","formula","sharpener","customer service","speed","coverage","eyeliner","application","blends","shadow","stick","lasting","pencil","tarte","works","eyeshadow","stays","buy","pigment","makeup","tip"].
"I love the color and liner texture. It is difficult to sharpen. Luckily I had a pencil sharpener large enough to fit it. The sharpener didn’t work that well. It would be great if one designed for the pencil came with it."
"Goes on smoothly and good color payoff. However, obsession color is so so sparkly. I really love the color but I'm going to throw in the trash due to the sparkles. I feel like I need to be 12 if I'm wearing this due to the amount of sparkles within the color. I'm really bummed. I don't mind a little shimmer / Pearl effect but this is just straight sparkles. As a 42 year old woman, it just doesn't look right in my personal opinion."
"I bought 4 different shades and I absolutely love the color of all of them. They double as a liner and an eyelid shade. Easy to apply and blend. However, the initial sharpened part doesn’t last long - maybe 3 applications at most. They don’t come with a sharpener and they are larger around so my regular sharpeners don’t work on them. I guess I’ll have to toss them and be out the money?"
"If it was with my time to send this back I would. The lack of color in this item is disappointing. It looks nothing like the photos. My eyes are green and this looked like a soft black color and not the gorgeous plum like on the model. I bought another from a different retailer for less than half the price of this one and the color is perfect. I’m going to give this away because I know I won’t be using it. I do like the application though. It went on very smoothly."
"I have multiple products like this from other brands that have a super easy twist up with a built in sharpener. I had no idea I would need to go buy a sharpener to even get to the rest of the product. I love the color and feel of it, but there are plenty of alternatives that make it more convenient."
"This eye pencil was awesome...I loved it so much I bought multiple colors. BUT when I went to sharpen it, that's when I ran into trouble. It's very jagged and I cut my eye. I keep trying to resharpen it but all I'm doing is wasting product and still can't get a nice tip. Sad cause now I have several colors and I'm scared to sharpen them knowing it won't ever be back to a nice pencil."
"I was so excited to find this shade because I had been looking for the bronze color I love from Tarte. When it first arrived, I loved the color and formula. Then I realized it has to be sharpened. I loathe makeup products that require sharpening, and this one needs a jumbo sharpener, which was surprisingly difficult to find. Even worse, the large tip has broken off three separate times while I was sharpening it. That is incredibly frustrating, especially considering the price and how much product is wasted each time. I also don’t see anything in the listing that clearly states that this pencil needs to be sharpened. Most of Tarte’s cream eyeshadow sticks twist up, which is one of the reasons I love them so much. Unfortunately, this one feels like money down the drain."
"I love my purchase; the description matches what I received, it arrived very quickly, and the colors are beautiful."
"I’m still getting use to it. But it is so much easier to use. Goes on easy, no stretching anything. Give u a perfect Smokey look. It brightens my eyes. I’ve never been able to do all that as easy or different products that fade away or by end of day it’s so smudged, it just makes you look tired. I definitely love it. & recommend it."
"I love Smoldereyes. Great color pay off. Great staying power. Lasts all day. Easy to use."
Language
Language changes site text only. Currency is based on your selected country. Translations are powered by AI.