Using for years! "This is my favorite liner. I’ve been using it for years. The liquid comes it smooth and easy. The other side is also smooth and creamy. Both stay all day. My only slight complaint it that the crayon side normally runs out before the liquid for me. Also, before I used Tarte my eyeliners would bother my eyes because I have bad allergies. Tarte doesn’t bother my eyes at all." — Kendra R. (5/5)
Still uncertain "I bought this for the first time. I do have a little trouble with the wet side having complete color on my under eye. It’s spotty. I’d say it’s not the best I’ve used but I really like the pencil." — Karen F. (3/5)
Will buy again "Works great. I like the pencil for my inner lid and the felt tip for outer lid. Doesn’t irritate. Stays well. Happy with my purchase." — jody s. (5/5)
Pencil side needs improvement "I have purchased two of these pencils. (Months apart) While I love the felt tip side for super thin lines, the pencil side of both I’ve owned have been dry and impossible to use. They crumble off as you try to line your eye. Super disappointing." — AG (3/5)
nice to have in brown "This is my 3rd time buying this product. This time I got it in the brown color and at first I thought it was not pigmented enough but after a few tries I was pleased with the color." — Nishat C. (5/5)