Love this! "I’m obsessed with the Tarte ModernEYES Shadow & Liner because it makes pulling together a polished eye look almost embarrassingly easy. Having a creamy eyeshadow stick on one end and a crisp liner on the other means you can go from zero to full-glam in under a minute. The shadow glides on like silk and blends out smoothly with just a fingertip, while the liner side adds instant depth without any awkward dragging. Once it sets, it locks in place without creasing or smudging all day, making it the ultimate secret weapon for quick morning routines or on-the-go touch-ups!" — Lisa T. (5/5)
Cute lil combo "Love the color payoff and how easy this is to use. The shadow and liner combo makes getting ready super quick, and it looks really pretty once applied. The formula feels smooth and blends nicely. My only issue is that the product keeps breaking, even when I’m careful with it, which is disappointing. Otherwise it would easily be 5 stars!" — Vaiva U. (4/5)
Ok not great "I love the concept but the eyeliner was hard to apply. I think it’s a quality issue." — Carly W. (3/5)
Nice combination product "This is a nice combination product. I love having the liner and smudge in one "stick". Great for days on the go and traveling. It can feel a little gritty if you use too much smudge. . . ." — Trudy B. (4/5)
No cream "How do you get the shadow to come out? It doesn’t produce enough shadow cream to color eye lids." — Terrie (2/5)
"Its just really difficult to use. Waste of money if you ask me. Pretty color, though." — Jaclyn (2/5)
"I do not like this one bit. The shadow smudging end doesnt to anything. And the liner end doesnt place well for me anyway. I prefer the fake awake liners over this all day. Its now a dust collector." — JoAnn (1/5)
Very dry liner, breaks easily. "Unfortunately the liner was very dry and broke off several times. It doesn’t glide at all, just breaks." — Maria W. (2/5)