You CAN sharpen these. And they last all day. "Get the very wide sharpener from a brand that starts with "R", pull the insert out. Sharpen these. $3 from a store "A". It works beautifully. The sharpener has 2 holes but can sharpen 3 sizes of pencils. Pull the insert out. You're golden. Don't miss out on these. I have 5 colors. Last all day, no touch-ups and don't embarrassed me. Makes my eyes look amazing!!" — JoLee (5/5)
"I love this color! It is so pretty with a darker brown or on its on! Application is easy, but the smudger is too hard and doesn’t work well. The liner atays put, even after many hours." — Kerry (5/5)
These eyeshadows are beautiful and "These eyeshadows are beautiful and long lasting. So convenient for travel too!" — Beth M. (5/5)
"I love this color and it stays well, but the smudger is very hard and the liner doesn’t blend well with it. I had better luck using my finger." — Kerry (4/5)
LOVE! "I never knew how much I needed this in my life before I got it! This liner goes on so smoothly and creates a little wider of a line so that it leaves the perfect shadow. I love my smolder color, and am looking forward to filling out the rest of my collection!" — Mandy D. (5/5)
love this product "love the color, love the performance. super easy to use. i want to purchase other colors." — Loa C. (5/5)
Versatility at your fingertips! "Love how you can create so many looks with just this one pencil. If you’re a no fuss kind of gal, definitely grab in several colors!" — Roslyn R. (5/5)
Poor design "Ordered this, loved the color n sparkle of it but the poor design of the pencil doesn’t let u sharpen it. Maybe if it was thinner 🤷🏽♀️ but more than half of it will b wasted. Unfortunate." — Caroline W. (2/5)
Smolder eyes "I love these chubby sticks of eye color! They give me the look I love to wear without working at layering the color. Easy and fast application. I have quite a few colors though I use black most often." — C O. (5/5)