This mascara is NOT waterproof AT ALL "I look like a raccoon with this after 10 minutes of wear. It makes dark under eye circles even just from blinking. I literally had to throw out two full mascara bottles because there was no way to make them not smear all over my under eyes and make me look terrible (and be embarrassed to no end)" — AE (1/5)
Finally! "Tried so many different type of mascara applicators. My short and thin eyelashes finally got the uplift they need it!" — eve b. (5/5)
Favorite mascara "This has been my favorite mascara for years! Love the applicator and fullness" — Samantha (5/5)
Love love love "Such a great mascara. It’s the only one I use anymore. Great definition and volume in one product!" — Alissa M. (5/5)
Smudged "Raccoon eyes within an hour. So bizarre because I love every other mascara from Tarte. They are always my go-to for lashes but this one missed the mark entirely. No idea why all the reviews don’t mention the smudging under the eyes because it happens almost immediately!" — Sarah F. (1/5)
Great mascara coverage "I love this mascara big ego, it's easy to find in my makeup bag because of the bright pink. Just need two coats and I'm good to go, non clumping and just thick and dense lashes." — Sabrina C. (5/5)