"Seems very dry, almost as if its an old tube. Bristles are very short, which cause you to get mascara on the eyelids. Water proof works as described. Overall disappointing for the $25 pricetag." — C (3/5)
"The best waterproof I have tried so far. No clumps and stays put until removed with eye makeup remover" — Mary (5/5)
Brush could be better "I like the formula of the mascara, but the brush doesn't do a very good job separating my lashes. The brush seems to always causes me to get mascara on the skin next to my eye and on my eye lid, which means I have to clean up around my eyes after I'm finished applying. I wish the brush head was a little smaller and the bristles more fine to separate lashes and reduce the globbiness." — Heather G. (4/5)
ANNOYING CONTAINER "This was the first waterproof version I purchased. I love the regular version. But my first thought when I opened the box was, "Am I supposed to remove this leather cover?" I googled it and discovered that this awkward cover keeps the user from closing the wand tightly enough after using to keep the mascara from drying out prematurely. Not a good marketing plan. I don't know that I will buy again." — KATHLEEN F. (3/5)
Tarte waterproof mascara "Once I tried this mascara I never tried another. I do a lot of Boating in the summer, and am 66 years old. This mascara does not smudge flake or come off until you want it to. It is flawless even when swimming. And comes off easy with a makeup remover pad. Love this product!" — cind b. (5/5)
My go-to mascara for 4+ yrs "The absolute best mascara, long stay and hold with curled lashes" — Rashelle D. (5/5)
Best Mascara "I have always worn waterproof mascara and Lights, Camera, Splashes is the best by far. It extends your lashes and makes them look full." — Tammy P. (5/5)
Great for Crying "I had to put my dog to sleep and could not stop crying, but this mascara held up. I definitely recommend for any sad occasions." — Ana (5/5)
Best waterproof mascara ever!!! "I just love this waterproof mascara, I have color Black and I love this formula. It washes off easily every night and since I am 65 years old and very busy watching my grandchildren, I have hardly anytime fussing with mascara. This is my go to every morning, easy application and out comes my lashes! Plus all my daughter's friends give me complements and I tell them why!" — Florence R. (5/5)