There’s nothing better! "I got this during a “build your own kit” promo and LOVED it. Once I finished it I thought I would try a cheaper brand and immediately realized why tarte’s is more expensive." — Chelsea B. (5/5)
Skip the navy and go for the bright blue "Beautiful mascara, always great quality, howeverrrrr… the darker blue shade- not recommended. No one can tell it’s blue. Get the bright blue shade if you want more than just you to know it’s not black mascara. I wish the color was more noticeable. I attached unretouched pics for reference." — Laura (4/5)
MY FAVORITE MASCARA EVER "I’ve tried so many mascaras from different brands and this is the best one! Removed easily and the consistency is amazing for application. I tried the XL gold mascara and it wasn’t as good. It took forever to dry and it uncurled my lashes. This formula is wayyy better and keeps my curled lashes stay curled and it’s not too heavy." — Gen (5/5)
Opinion of a mascara snob! "This mascara is absolutely my holy grail! And I am an unapologetic mascara snob. I can't resist trying new mascaras and I have yet to find one that even holds a candle to this one! It is absolutely the one I constantly recommend on my LTK and my Instagram and in my blog! If you want gorgeous, long lashes, THIS is the answer!!" — Kalii (5/5)
LOVE THIS MASCARA "I have tried several different brands over the years and this is by far the best. I just ordered in brown hopefully I will love it too!" — Ky (5/5)
Good but not my favorite "I tried this mascara first and was a fan of it, but it simply does not compare to the tartelette XL. I found that this one is just a little bit smudgier, and does not have quite the same perfect tubing effect that the XL does. If you try this one first, I imagine you will love it, but if you try it after trying the XL, you might be disappointed." — Alyssa (4/5)
